Baking cookies at 401°F (205°C) has produced the best balance between a set structure and a still-moist center in tests.
That middle heat helps explain why some batches turn cakey, dry, or greasy when the oven runs cooler or hotter.
Cookies in the lab
In a pilot-scale oven at the University of Guelph in Ontario, Canada, identical cookie rounds are baked under tightly controlled heat and timing.
By tracking changes throughout each bake, Dr. Maria G. Corradini, an associate professor at Guelph, tied oven heat to spread and moisture loss.
Across the bake, heat drove early spreading, while disappearing water later decided whether cookies stayed thick or tightened into thinner rounds.
Once that handoff happens, a recipe can fail even when the clock looks right, because the dough dries at different speeds.
Three temperatures tested
To make the bake predictable, a paper followed one standard dough at three temperatures.
Each batch spent up to 12 minutes in the oven, and the team pulled cookies every two minutes for measurements.
At 437°F (225°C), cookies reached their widest point at about four minutes, then shrank as fast drying stiffened the dough.
Those same rounds peaked later at 401°F (205°C), around six minutes, and the lower heat allowed spreading to continue at a slower pace through 12 minutes.
The critical first minutes
Early in the bake, softened fat turned the dough loose enough to flow outward across the hot pan surface.
As heat rose, trapped water began to steam and leavening gases formed, pushing tiny pockets that briefly lifted the cookie.
Higher temperatures sped up that soft stage, so cookies spread quickly before the outer layer firmed into a crust.
For bakers chasing a thick center, the first few minutes mattered most because heat decided how far the dough ran.
Moisture loss and texture
Later in the bake, evaporation stole enough water to turn the dough from flexible to rigid, and shape changes reversed.
With less moisture, starches and proteins locked into place, and the cookie stopped spreading and began tightening instead.
After 12 minutes, the hottest batch ended up driest, while the middle setting held onto more moisture than 437°F (225°C).
So moisture loss controlled both texture and color, since a drier surface browned faster as baking continued.
When color develops
Browning accelerated when the surface dried enough for the Maillard reaction – a heat-driven browning between sugars and proteins.
Once moisture fell, the cookie went from pale to golden and then darker as heat kept concentrating sugars.
During the hottest bakes, color climbed fast early, then eased late as the surface dried past the best browning range.
Color became a rough timer, but a deep brown top often signaled that the center had already dried out.
Why edges brown first
Within each cookie, edges warmed faster than centers, and the bottom ran hotter because it sat on metal.
Direct contact with the pan pushed heat into the base, while evaporation cooled the top and slowed browning there.
Thermal camera scans showed a ring that heated sooner, matching the darker band that appeared on the top surface.
Uneven heating meant a cookie could look done on the rim while the middle still felt soft and moist.
Turning data into models
The team described how they converted repeated baking measurements into a working model.
Rather than treating every change as steady, the model tracked reaction kinetics, measuring how quickly food reactions unfold over time.
The researchers noted that many food processes are often treated as linear, even though real reactions speed up and slow down as conditions change.
Once a model predicts when spreading stops and browning starts, bakers can tune time and heat with fewer surprises.
Safety and efficiency
Beyond texture, darker baking can raise acrylamide, a chemical that can form during high-heat cooking.
Keeping heat moderate limited extreme browning in the tests, which also reduced the time the surface sat at very high temperatures.
“The food industry is not known for its amazing modeling,” Corradini said, describing why bakeries still rely on trial and error.
Better models could help large bakeries cut wasted batches, shorten bake trials, and save energy without sending out underdone products.
Why recipes vary
Perfection stayed out of reach because crisp and soft mean different things to different people and different recipes.
Different sugars brown at different speeds, and fats melt on their own schedules, so two doughs rarely behave alike.
Because the equations fit one standard formula, big ingredient swaps or cookie sizes would need fresh measurements to stay accurate.
So 401°F (205°C) worked as a reliable starting point, not a rule that can rescue every oven and every pan.
A steadier cookie
Watching cookies change minute by minute showed that the best bakes balanced quick spreading in the first minutes with more gradual moisture loss later in the bake.
As Corradini refines the math for other foods, that same balance could make baking more consistent in homes and factories.
The study is published in the Journal of Food Science
—–
Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates.
Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and Earth.com.
—–